Thumbnail 1
Thumbnail 2
Thumbnail 3
Thumbnail 4
Thumbnail 5
Thumbnail 6
Thumbnail 7
Thumbnail 8
Thumbnail 9
Thumbnail 10

Images and floorplans are provided for illustrative purposes and remain the property of their respective copyright owners.

5 First Avenue
Rutherford, NSW 2320

3
Bed
1
Bath
1
Cars
Property Type: House
Listed Date: 26th Mar 2026
Overview

5 First Avenue, Rutherford NSW 2320

Set behind a welcoming façade and showcasing solid craftsmanship, this well-maintained brick and tile home offers a harmonious blend of retro charm and practical living. The property has been carefully preserved and presents an excellent opportunity for first home buyers seeking confidence in their purchase, as well as investors looking for a ready-to-go addition to their portfolio.

Currently tenanted on a periodic lease, the home provides immediate rental income while maintaining flexibility for future plans. Upon entering, wide and spacious hallways create an open atmosphere, connecting a separate formal lounge and three generously sized bedrooms.

The dedicated dining area flows seamlessly into the updated kitchen, designed for ease of meal preparation and entertaining. At the rear, a second large living area offers versatile space for families to relax, unwind, or gather together, providing a layout that is more expansive than it initially appears. Comfort is ensured year-round with split system reverse cycle air conditioning.

Outside, the property features a well-kept, fully fenced yard and a large workshop or storage shed that could easily serve as a covered entertaining area. Accessibility has been thoughtfully incorporated with external ramps and internal railings, making the home suitable for a diverse range of buyers and lifestyles.

Conveniently located within easy reach of local shops, schools, and transport, and approximately five minutes from Maitland CBD, this property offers immediate comfort, long-term potential, and instant income. It represents a well-rounded opportunity that meets the needs of both home buyers and investors.

Location
5 First Avenue
Rutherford NSW 2320
Market Insights for Rutherford NSW 2320
New Listings (last 30 days)
8
Average price
$2,196,875
Lowest price
$450,000
Highest price
$5,000,000
Other properties in this postcode
41 Roxburgh Street, Lorn NSW 2320
Auction
41 Roxburgh Street, Lorn NSW 2320
3 beds 1 bath 1 car
591 Hermitage Road, PokolbinPrice on request NSW 2320
$4,000,000
456 Hermitage Road, PokolbinGuide NSW 2320
696 Mcdonalds Road, PokolbinPrice on request NSW 2320
$2,800,000
595 Hermitage Road, PokolbinGuide NSW 2320
$750,000
4 Quinton Close, RutherfordGuide NSW 2320

* Search brackets are a technical classification derived from unverified metadata set by the listing agent for search filtering. It is not an official price guide, a valuation, or a representation of the seller's reserve. This data is provided for search transparency purposes only.